|
|
|
News From 1922
By Ed Driscoll · October 31, 2008 12:24 PM · Muggeridge's Law · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Memory Hole
As Tom Blumer writes in Newsbusters, put down all beverages before reading this quote from Al Neuharth, extracted from his column in today's edition of USA Today: In the olden days, some newspapers actually were backed or funded by political parties. Not only did most endorse candidates, but news coverage often was slanted or opinionated.OK, to be fair, if you define "the olden days" to mean the era before the national radio networks, that's reasonable--and the era that followed, which was centered around a unified mass media, served the American public reasonably well until about 1968. But Victor Davis Hanson writes today, as I noted in an earlier post today, that era was shattered by the rise of the World Wide Web and replaced with a hyperpartisan advocacy media--which isn't necessarily a bad thing, as long consumers know that that's what their getting, and not a continued feint towards objectivity. An increasing number of journalists understand that. But to borrow from an earlier post, there are those stragglers, such as Neuharth, whom every year sound more and more like the mythological Japanese soldier discovered on a desert island years after World War II ended, who doesn't realize the war's over, and how it concluded. The Asphalt Jungle
By Ed Driscoll · October 31, 2008 12:10 PM · Bobos In Paradise · The Future and its Enemies · The Making of the President
In repairing our nation's rapidly aging infrastructure, count me as very much one of the "Pro-Pavement People" that Matthew Continetti mentions here, as opposed to "The desire named streetcar." Then And Now, Backing The Man With The Mustache
By Ed Driscoll · October 31, 2008 11:02 AM · Liberal Fascism · The Making of the President · War And Anti-War
Reader Patrick Cox sent me a link to this Reuters piece, titled, "WITNESS: Berliners' love affair with America grows cold". Here's a sample: During the 1990s pro-American sentiment was still high.Which brings Germany full circle: having been liberated by the US after their feverish support of a genocidal mustachioed tyrant, Germany is apparently peeved at the US because we defeated another nation's genocidal mustachioed tyrant. Yet curiously, that nation seems pretty happy not to be under Saddam's yoke. (Triangulation spotted here; potential for deja vu all over again, here.) Update: The proprietor of the Bitter Sanity blog spots a little time traveling going on, and emails: From the article you just commented on:I'm surprised that made it through Reuters' layers and layers of fact checkers.It was, of course, the dispute over the invasion of Iraq.Um... people protesting an invasion that didn't start until ten months later? Prescient, those Germans. "Operation Investor Class Rollback"
By Ed Driscoll · October 31, 2008 10:25 AM · Capitalism, the Unknown Ideal · The Making of the President
James Pethokoukis explains "Why Democrats Will Target the Investor Class in 2009": If Barack Obama is elected president next week, 2009 may well bring a concerted and all-out effort by the Obama administration and a Democratically dominated Congress to turn the generally pro-Republican Investor Class into an endangered class by, among other tactics, raising investment taxes and ending the tax preferences for 401(k)'s, IRAs, and other retirement accounts.Via Betsy Newmark, who writes, "watch for it. Don't say you weren't warned." Update: More via the Professor. Joe Klein--Still In The Fever Swamp
By Ed Driscoll · October 31, 2008 09:53 AM · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Newspeak Dictionary · War And Anti-War
Back in June, the liberal New Republic noted that Joe Klein took Time magazine's "Swampland" blog into the fever swamp, when he wrote: The fact that a great many Jewish neoconservatives--people like Joe Lieberman and the crowd over at Commentary--plumped for this war, and now for an even more foolish assault on Iran, raised the question of divided loyalties: using U.S. military power, U.S. lives and money, to make the world safe for Israel. And then there is the question--made manifest by the no-bid contracts offered U.S. oil companies by the Iraqis--of two oil executives, Bush and Cheney, securing a new source of business for their Texas buddies.James Kirchick of TNR replied: "Raised the question of divided loyalties?" Why doesn't Klein just come out and answer the "question," instead of cowardly using a vague, past tense construction, and say that a cabal of Jews agitated a War for Israel? His suggestion that they advocated "using U.S. lives and money to make the world safe for Israel" is the exact same sort of thing Pat Buchanan said about the First Gulf War (remarks that led his former mentor William F. Buckley Jr. to label him an anti-Semite).With Klient's latest writing... I've never met Rashid Khalidi, but he is (a) Palestinian and therefore (b) a semite, so the charge of anti-semitism is fatuous....He's still in the fever swamp, as Jeffery Goldberg of The Atlantic writes: I want to be absolutely clear that I'm not about to accuse Joe of being an anti-Semite, but I will note that this the first time I've ever heard a Jewish person, or a non-anti-Semite, make this sort of malicious statement, one that perverts the universal meaning of a term in order to mock the phenomenon of Jew-hatred. "Jew-hatred" is actually my preferred term, because, as I'm sure Joe knows, "anti-Semitism" was a term invented by the avant-garde Jew-hater Wilhelm Marr, who was the founder, in 1879, of the League of Anti-Semites, which argued that Germans and Jews were locked in a death struggle for racial superiority. And we know where that ended.You stay classy, Time magazine. The Duellists
By Ed Driscoll · October 31, 2008 09:40 AM · The Return of the Primitive
"Disgruntled Congressman Hastings Threatens Life of Opponent Marion Thorpe"--everything old is new again! I Thought Dissent Was Patriotic
Hey, Thomas Jefferson said so and everything--but just in time for the final descent of his campaign, "Obama kicks dissenting reporters off plane." But then, as Victor Davis Hanson writes, "Sometime in 2008, journalism as we knew it died, and advocacy media took its place"--a trend I've been tracking since early 2004. (And these guys since the mid-1980s.) Reality...What A Concept
Marvel Comics and Mark Steyn's America Alone thesis on demographic decline team up for all of the two-fisted, one-handed imaginary action you can handle! A Japanese man has enlisted hundreds of people in a campaign to allow marriages between humans and cartoon characters, saying he feels more at ease in the "two-dimensional world".Sounds like somebody's due for a nice long rest in Arkham Asylum. Besides--there's a larger marital issue which clearly Mr. Takashita hasn't considered. Since it's reasonable to assume that the most popular female cartoon characters would have thousands--nay, millions of male suitors, why, that's bigamy! Tale Of The Tape
By Ed Driscoll · October 30, 2008 10:34 PM · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Making of the President · War And Anti-War
If you want to get up to speed quickly on the background behind the Khalidi-Obama tape that the L.A. Times is sitting on, then I strongly recommend the 10-minute or so interview on PJTV between Roger L. Simon and Ben Shapiro. Click through Roger's post, here. The L.A. Times is infamous for its 3,500-word hit piece which ran in 2003 on then California gubernatorial candidate Arnold Schwarzenegger. It hit the streets in--when else?--October of that year. Gosh, wonder why the Times is treading so lightly this time around? (Gateway Pundit suggests the paper maybe interested in safety and protection over and over both mere politics.) Related: "This Is the Khalidi Obama Embraced". "What They're Forgetting About The Forgotten Man"
By Ed Driscoll · October 30, 2008 06:28 PM · Capitalism, the Unknown Ideal · Liberal Fascism · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole
Amity Shlaes reminds us that yes indeed, FDR's policies prolonged the Depression--or as Mark Steyn wrote at the start of the month: "Lots of other places -- from Britain to Australia -- took a hit in 1929 but, alas, they lacked an FDR to keep it going till the end of the Thirties. That's why in other countries they refer to it as "the Depression," but only in the U.S. is it 'Great.'"For most of the 1970s, Archie and Edith sang, "Mister, we could use a man like Herbert Hoover again." It took a few decades, but at long last, their wish finally comes true. Meanwhile, Charles Johnson spots one huge budget-busting proposal from Obama, which is troubling not just for its fiscal excess. Standing Athwart History, Yelling "More Vermouth!"
By Ed Driscoll · October 30, 2008 05:01 PM · Bobos In Paradise · Muggeridge's Law · The Making of the President
As a connoisseur of fine conservative satire, I must say, I do rather like the cut of this "Iowahawk" fellow's jib: When my late father T. Coddington Van Voorhees VI founded the iconoclastic conservative journal National Topsider in 1948, he famously declared that "Now is the time for all good conservative helmsmen to hoist the mizzen, pour the cocktails, and steer this damned schooner hard starboard." In the 60 years since he first uttered it after one-too-many Cosmopolitans at one of Pamela Harriman's notorious foreign policy black tie balls, father's pithy bon mot has served as a rallying cry for conservatives from Greenwich to Chevy Chase. Today, I say it's time for we conservatives to once again grab the rigging and set sail with the flotilla of the true conservative in this race: Barack Obama.Do I even need to add the "read the whole thing" encomium here? The Mirror Speaks, The Reflection Lies
By Ed Driscoll · October 30, 2008 12:36 PM · Liberal Fascism · The Future and its Enemies · The Making of the President · The Return of the Primitive
Babalu Blog notes, accurately, I think, that "It's a lose-lose proposition for Obama's supporters": On November 4th, Barack Obama just might win the presidential election. But regardless of whether he wins or loses, the vast majority of his supporters will lose. If McCain wins the election, they will feel the sting of watching the candidate they placed all their hopes in be defeated. But it stands to be much worse for them if their candidate wins.Which is why, "If I were John McCain's campaign, I would have just bought enough time to run this video after Obama's infomercial..." Related: "America the Miserable." (Speaking of mirrors and reflections.) Back Off, Man--I'm A Scientist
By Ed Driscoll · October 30, 2008 11:51 AM · The Making of the President
The candidate as Rorschach test: Jennifer Rubin writes that Sarah Palin is every candidate you want her to be--and more. Meanwhile, Roger L. Simon analyzes Obama's inkblot results. (Just don't cross the streams.) Flashback: "Get Over Objectivity, Newspapers"
By Ed Driscoll · October 30, 2008 02:58 AM · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Assault On Reason · The Making of the President
A year ago, Editor & Publisher ran a story with the above headline, in reference to climate change. (Article text available here) Sufficed to say, the industry has taken their house organ's advice deeply to heart on a variety of other topics as well--with less than satisfactory results to their collective net worth. He Did It Live--#$%@ It!
By Ed Driscoll · October 30, 2008 02:07 AM · Capitalism, the Unknown Ideal · Oh, That Liberal Media!
That's a youthful, if momentarily glazed-looking Bill O'Reilly in the above YouTube clip from a news update twenty years ago (and about five years before this now-viral moment referenced in the above headline). Note the position of the Dow at the end of the segment, which provides some surprisingly reassuring contrast for where it stands today. Is McCain's Glass Half Full, Or Half Empty?
Something for the optimists and pessimists at Pajamas Media HQ--and if the latter group are proven correct, some thoughts on who will blamed the most and why, and yet may very well be the party's best hope in the near term future--although the latter conventional wisdom doesn't always survive the campaign trail. The Original Red Scare
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 10:03 PM · Hollywood, Interrupted · Liberal Fascism · War And Anti-War
As Michael Wade notes, "On this day in 1938, Martians landed in New Jersey", courtesy of Orson Welles' radio program and H.G. Wells' novel. Sadly, I suspect the latter would probably be pretty cool with what the writer of the latest movie version of his book used them to metaphorically stand-in for. Meanwhile, James Lileks squares the circle, and John Nolte has additional Halloween movie selections. Though for us veteran connoisseurs of Philadelphia TV of our boomer youth, it's just not the same without Dr. Shock or Stella, "that Maneater from Manayunk" introducing them. Update: And speaking of Philadelphia, congrats to the Phillies! Head For The Gulch!
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 08:20 PM · Capitalism, the Unknown Ideal · The Making of the President
Amanda Carpenter catches a sly moment of numerical slight-of-hand as well in the Obamamercial, for those thinking of going John Galt next year. Even Better Than The Real Thing
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 07:32 PM · Capitalism, the Unknown Ideal · Muggeridge's Law · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Making of the President
Biggest celebrity in the world already known for his faux-presidential seal and other self-reverential campaign graphics produces infomercial on mock-White House set. Chris Matthews' take? "It was romance. It was realism." More human than human is our motto. But like another product of the Tyrell Corporation, does Obama see unicorns when he dreams? The Daisy Ad That Never Was
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 07:10 PM · Liberal Fascism · Radical Chic · The Making of the President
![]() The Weekly Standard's blog looks at "what might have been." Kudlow & Company
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 04:16 PM · Capitalism, the Unknown Ideal · Ed On The Radio · The Making of the President · The Return of the Primitive
Larry Kudlow talks presidential economics on this week's edition of PJM Political, also featuring James Lileks' warm remembrance of Dean Barnett, and a round-table pre-postmortem of next week's election featuring Steve Green, Lileks, Ed Morrissey of Hot Air and myself. And you'll never look at Five Easy Pieces the same way again! Obama Shrugged
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 02:40 PM · The Making of the President
"Shining a light on the Obama fundraising machine"--and its curious list of donors. The Key Phrase Being "Mixed Lot"
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 02:29 PM · Bobos In Paradise · Muggeridge's Law · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole
Check out this howler in a piece in CQ Politics titled, "What McCain Defectors See in Obama": The defectors are a mixed lot, but all represent some brand of recognizably conservative thought. Some like Doug Kmiec, Andrew Sullivan, and Ken Adelman are probably conservatives by anyone's definition, while others are cut partly from an older mold. They bear some resemblance to the moderate Republicanism of the Rockefeller era, but the issues of their time are not the same.Sullivan is as conservative these days as much as John Kerry was "the right man -- and the conservative choice -- for a difficult and perilous time." (H/T: Orrin Judd, whose link to Powers' essay is titled, "Inherit The Windbags.") Sweet Memory Hole, Chicago
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 02:05 PM · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole
"There's a wealth of information that would help define Obama just waiting -- and waiting -- for the press to discover", Abraham H. Miller writes, in a piece titled Obama's Chicago Secrets": But maybe CNN and the rest of the electronic media won't send anyone to Chicago because it is blowing its investigative budget flying reporters to Alaska to explore why anyone would fire a public safety director who refused to dismiss a state trooper who tasered a twelve year old boy -- a trooper who was reported to be drunk while on duty, and who allegedly threatened someone's life. Now, there is a story we all can believe in -- "Troopergate."Don't worry, the media will apologize for not doing what was once thought of as its job. After their man crosses the finish line next week. Howard Dean, Then And Now
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 01:53 PM · Bobos In Paradise · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole
Back in 2005, Howard Dean told the late Tim Russert that "I will use whatever position I have in order to root out hypocrisy." This seems like an exceptional place to start. Down The Memory Hole
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 12:51 PM · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole
While my Ministry of Truth video on Monday dealt primarily with the ability to pivot history on a 180-degree fulcrum, as an additional feature, it's worth noting that the modern news media's primary role is not to disseminate information, but to withhold it. Sometimes permanently, or simply holding it back until it won't do much damage to a favored patron, at which point it can be released on page D-17 of the late Friday edition of the paper, in a two or three paragraph article in nine-point type next to the local plumber's advertisement and supermarket coupons. The drawback to this approach of course, is that if there's a hint that the paper is sitting on a story, it can lead to wild--or who knows?--overly mild speculation about its contents. All of which is why "2008 is not a year on which honest journalists shall look back with undiluted pleasure." New Silicon Graffiti Video--"Live From The Ministry Of Truth"
By Ed Driscoll · October 29, 2008 08:00 AM · All You Need Is Ears · Ed TV · Hollywood, Interrupted · Liberal Fascism · The Future and its Enemies · The Gulag Archipelago · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole · The Newspeak Dictionary · War And Anti-War
In the latest edition of Silicon Graffiti videoblog, we visit industrious Outer Party Member Winston Smith hard at work in the Ministry of Truth, and look at how history can be turned on a dime, including:
This is the 19th edition of our ongoing Silicon Graffiti videoblog series, which began in January of this year; click here for all of the previous editions. Crush With Eyeliner
By Ed Driscoll · October 27, 2008 09:40 PM · The Making of the President · The Return of the Primitive
Jules Crittenden wonders if insane neo-Nazis have mutated into an even weirder hybrid of "AndrogeNazis": Hey, is it just me or does that neo-Nazi assassination plotter look like maybe he goosesteps with the left jackboot as well as the right? You know, siegheils from both sides of the Nuremberg rally. Like maybe his death train rattles in both directions.Maybe he's an Ernest Rohm fan. Dean Barnett Has Passed Away
By Ed Driscoll · October 27, 2008 01:06 PM · The New, New Journalism
I let out an audible gasp when I read the news a few minutes ago, even though I knew he had been ailing: Dean Barnett dead at the far-too-young age of 41. You can hear my interview with Dean from last November, here. Update: The Weekly Standard has a round-up of blogger and pundit memorials to Dean, here. You Only Live Twice
By Ed Driscoll · October 26, 2008 08:51 PM · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole · The Return of the Primitive
As Power Line notes, over at the once-respect publication The Atlantic, Andrew Sullivan has posted (under the same headline) a YouTube video trashing Sarah Palin titled, "Red, White and MILF." John Hinderaker responds: I don't think there is any precedent in our history for the shameful manner in which the Left has treated Sarah Palin. Left-winger Andrew Sullivan gleefully posted a particularly disgusting example of the phenomenon today; it's a YouTube video titled "Red, White and MILF." Watch it only if you have a strong stomach. If you don't know what "MILF" means--I'm sure most of our readers don't--Google it.Sadly, that's been true for a number of years now. But from time to time, some have called the left on their actions. Here's a pioneering member of the Blogosphere in 2002 on the dangers of racism, invective and ad hominem attacks emanating from the left: When a black public person like Harry Belafonte calls another African-American a slave to white masters, you see what I mean. When defenders of feminism call someone who files a sexual harassment lawsuit "trailer-trash," you get the picture. When a gay man can write a column asserting that another man is a "nasty faggot," it's hard to think of how much lower the discourse can get. When liberals denigrate the president as a "boy" or as a "sissy," to quote Maureen Dowd, homophobia doesn't lurk far behind.That blogger's name? Andrew Sullivan, oddly enough. Obama Flunks SOX
By Ed Driscoll · October 26, 2008 12:35 PM · Capitalism, the Unknown Ideal · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole
Sarbanes-Oxley? That's strictly for those Joe the Plumber-type suckers in the private sector, writes TigerHawk: Mark Steyn has more on the hilarious and probably intentional failure of internal controls at the Obama campaign. If it were a public company it would have to disclose a material weakness, and its auditors would wonder whether its "tone from the top" had actually encouraged the practices in question. Fortunately for politicians of all parties, we do not hold government to anything like the same standard of accountability that applies to private businesses with public stockholders.Reviewing the last weeks of a campaign that seems like it commenced "sometime during your first child's initial year in primary school", Tim Blairadds, "this is just a guess, but it could be that the rules are different for Democrats." (Video found via Little Green Footballs.) Laphamization Alert!
As Nick Schulz of Tech Central Station spotted in late August of 2004, Harper's magazine editor Lewis Lapham "wrote about the GOP convention speeches before anyone even stepped to the podium": But the only "mistake" Lapham made is in revealing for all to see what has long been known by anyone who pays attention to the news: the major media routinely bring to their coverage of significant political events a predetermined storyline -- you might want to call it a "Lapham". Facts that undermine the storyline are ignored or explained away as aberrations to The Truth. For the editor of Harper's and other establishment press figures, it really makes no difference to them what will be said at Madison Square Garden because the Laphams are already set, loaded in the scribblers' word processors and television anchor tele-prompters and ready to go.Or maybe these days it's best known as Ifillization, but New York magazine also jumps the gun a bit on the results of the election, just as multiple members of Lapham's Blue Media did in 2004. More On Mapes' "Monster", Plus Blue Is The New Yellow
By Ed Driscoll · October 26, 2008 11:58 AM · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Making of the President · The New, New Journalism
Scott Johnson of Power Line --part of the "monster" that Mary Mapes, inadvertently helped to create when deliberately cooked the books at CBS in 2004 (back when viewers were still surprised that such things occurred), has some thoughts on her post this week at the Puffington Host. He reaches a conclusion similar to my take from Friday. As to Big Media in 2008, the Professor and his readers have some thoughts on the state of "Blue Journalism." Think Of The Matrix--With The Soundtrack By The Bee Gees
By Ed Driscoll · October 26, 2008 11:23 AM · All You Need Is Ears · Muggeridge's Law · The Assault On Reason · The Making of the President · The New Puritans
"Joe Biden's RAVE Act of 2002 was a terrible blow against dance-generated alternative energy." Is It News, Or Is It CNN?
By Ed Driscoll · October 25, 2008 07:12 PM · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Making of the President · The Memory Hole
A half century ago, Marshall McLuhan noted: The bias of each medium of communication is far more distorting than the deliberate lie. The form and tone of some press styles may make the very concept of truth irrelevant. The most urgent and reliable facts presented in this way are a travesty of any reality.And that was during the (surprisingly brief) era in which a mass media feigned objectivity--and might have even believed it themselves. McLuhan's observation is even more true these days, as Roger L. Simon writes. Update: Rick Moran may have caught CNN in yet another fabrication. Hey Mighty Brontosaurus, Don't You Have A Lesson For Us?
Steve Green writes: Sixty-five million years ago, dinosaurs ruled the earth -- with the same unthinking ruthlessness which Rep John Murtha (D, PA-12) rules the House Defense Subcommittee. His own website brags that "[o]f the nearly 10,000 men and women who have served in the U.S. House of Representatives since 1789, only 90 have served longer than he has." But maybe, just maybe, like the dinosaurs, Murtha's time is up.He's long overdue for a nice long vacation on the beach at Okinawa. Compare And Contrast
A reporter for Newsweek has no problem admitting to the world that he'd like to take out Rudy Giuliani--in a nonlethal way of course; "just something that put him out of commission for a year or so." But if a journalist asks tough questions of The One's veep nominee, she's immediately put on the defensive for doing her job and not merely being a cheerleader. "The News Business Is Already In A Depression"
By Ed Driscoll · October 25, 2008 05:29 PM · Capitalism, the Unknown Ideal · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Future and its Enemies
Certainly in terms of their collective mental health, we know that to be true from the yin and yang of the Michael Malone and Mary Mapes posts we linked to yesterday, but the Professor also spots, as he calls it, more media retrenchment: "The Star-Ledger of Newark, N.J., will reduce its newsroom staff by nearly half through voluntary buyouts as New Jersey's largest newspaper seeks to return to profitability." Whatever happens to the rest of the world, the news business is already in a depression.And just as it did with the economic slowdowns in the early 1990s and the period surrounding 9/11, there's little doubt the media's own woes are coloring how they report the business news outside of their industry. Sneak Preview: Adobe CS4
By Ed Driscoll · October 25, 2008 11:59 AM · An Army Of Davids · Ed On The 'Net · Pajamas Theater 3000
It's been a while since I've posted at Blogcritics, but I have some initial impressions over there of the beta version of Adobe CS4, focusing on Photoshop, Premiere Pro and After Effects, all of which have some spiffy new features. I hope to follow-up with the final release version in the not too distant future. What A Run! From Navel Gazers To Monsters In Seven Years
By Ed Driscoll · October 24, 2008 04:59 PM · An Army Of Davids · Bobos In Paradise · Muggeridge's Law · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Long Tail · The Making of the President · The New, New Journalism
Mary Mapes, the woman who brought you RatherGate, wrote yesterday at the Huffington Post: Americans aren't responding to the old plays -- the fake fears, the faux outrage, the conservatives who yell "Communist" at the news cameras, the pompous right-wing bloggers who once held such sway. I know all too well how scary and effective these old tactics were in 2004. Today, they are toothless. Ha, ha. Nothing makes me happier than seeing once swaggering players like Powerline, Free Republic and Little Green Footballs forced onto the sidelines, left to limply watch this campaign pass by like a parade in which they play no meaningful part. They just don't matter anymore.Mapes' post is titled, "The Monster is Dying"--so "conservatives who yell 'Communist' at the news cameras" are declasse, but attacking conservatives as a monolithic "monster" on a Weblog is reasoned nuance journalism. Charles Krauthammer, call your office! But behind each of those "monsters" was at least one person who in one form another said, "I don't know how many people will actually listen, but why shouldn't my voice be heard as well?" (Just as the founder of the Huffington Post presumably said as well at some point.) Much like a certain Ohio tradesman with entrepreneurial dreams who is now called "the now infamous Joe the plumber," on over 500 Webpages. Or as another journalist with the same initials as Mary Mapes wrote today: So much for the Standing Up for the Little Man, so much for Speaking Truth to Power, so much for Comforting the Afflicting and Afflicting the Comfortable, and all of those other catchphrases we journalists used to believe we lived by.And calling one half of the Blogosphere "toothless" because their presidential candidate isn't an effective purveyor of the same message as they are seems awfully disingenuous to the other side--I don't think the bloggers at, say, the Daily Kos would take kindly at being called, by extension, toothless in 2004 because John Kerry was such a feckless candidate. It also fails to take into consideration that pundits supporting the out-of-party are able to go on the rhetorical offense, something that the right-hand of the Blogosphere will likely have ample opportunity to do so over the next four years. But if indeed "The Monster is Dying", what a run! In September of 2005, a year after RatherGate broke, Mapes admitted that she had never heard of any of the blogs that she quotes above, even as she was a working TV producer at a corporation which billed itself at the time as "America's Most Watched Network", and hence, presumably, had her pulse on the nation's political scene: Within a few minutes, I was online visiting Web sites I had never heard of before: Free Republic, Little Green Footballs, Power Line. They were hard-core, politically angry, hyperconservative sites loaded with vitriol about Dan Rather and CBS. Our work was being compared to that of Jayson Blair, the discredited New York Times reporter who had fabricated and plagiarized stories.And accurately so, of course. But hey, from cat food eating pajama-wearing navel gazers to a journalistic "monster" in the space of seven years after 9/11 is a pretty amazing growth cycle--and something tells me that the starboard side of the Blogosphere isn't going away anytime soon, no matter how much Mary wishes it were so, and no matter what the outcome on November 4th. Gray Lady Logic
By Ed Driscoll · October 24, 2008 03:27 PM · Bobos In Paradise · Liberal Fascism · Oh, That Liberal Media! · The Future and its Enemies · The Making of the President · The New Puritans
Kevin D. Williamson asks readers to "Explain this reasoning to me": According to the geniuses at the Times, the governor of Alaska is self-evidently and grossly unqualified to be vice president of the United States, but a pop singer is obviously qualified to be lecturing the world about African civil wars and developmental economics. |